Executive Order 6102 and the 1933–34 Gold Orders
Executive Order 6102, signed on April 5, 1933, was revoked on August 28, 1933, by a new order that kept every liability under it alive.
Watch (film): He Sued His Bank for 27 Gold Bars. Within Two Days: Indicted on Gilt & Graft
Watch (short film): A 1934 Gold Seizure: What the Court Opinion Says on Gilt & Graft
Paper Trail: Paper Trail No. 3: Executive Order 6102, a $6 PDF with every claim matched to its source.
The short version
On March 6, 1933, the President declared "a bank holiday," saying there had been "heavy and unwarranted withdrawals of gold and currency from our banking institutions for the purpose of hoarding." President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed Executive Order 6102 on April 5, 1933. For anyone who "willfully violates" it, the penalty was a fine of not more than $10,000, or for a natural person, up to ten years in prison, or both. The order ended with the line "This order and these regulations may be modified or revoked at any time." Executive Order 6102 was revoked on August 28, 1933, by the order that replaced it, which revoked the April 5 and April 20 orders but kept every liability under them alive.
Frederick Barber Campbell, a lawyer in New York City, deposited thirteen bars of gold bullion, and then fourteen more, with the Chase National Bank of the City of New York for safekeeping. The bank agreed in writing to keep them and "return them to Campbell on demand." The bank wrote to Campbell, warning that thirty days after the August 28 order it would be "required to surrender any gold in our possession not covered by a license." Campbell demanded his gold, and a vice president of the bank refused, saying "we do not feel that we are in a position to deliver this gold to you at the present time." The Treasury's regulations had set September 18 as the last day for filing returns, and Campbell filed none. Campbell sued the bank, asking the court to order it to hand his gold back, and within two days he was indicted.
The charge was not hoarding. It was failing to file the return by September 18. A superseding indictment on October 5 added a second count, keeping his interest in the gold without a license, against section 5 of the August order. One Washington front page described the lawyer as indicted as a hoarder after suing for his gold, while the Evening Star's editorial page in Washington said he was not charged with hoarding.
Judge John M. Woolsey ruled on every part of the case. He dismissed the suit against the bank, saying the federal court had no jurisdiction over what he called "one of the most ancient of legal relationships," a bailment. He also dismissed the suit to stop the prosecution, because Campbell had "an adequate remedy at law" in the criminal case. He described the President's power to require returns from people who owned gold as "unimpeachable," but held that section 5, the ban on keeping gold without a license, was "in effect, confiscatory" and invalid. The second count was dismissed, but the first count stood, and Woolsey ruled that Campbell "must stand trial" for not filing the return. Woolsey also called the choice facing owners of gold bullion "surely not a fair alternative to set before a citizen."
On December 28, 1933, the Secretary of the Treasury issued an order of his own, under the power Congress had given him, and set the deadline at midnight of January 17, 1934. Campbell's bars were already gone: on January 2, 1934, the bank surrendered his gold to the Treasurer of the United States, on an order from the Secretary of the Treasury. On January 30, 1934, Roosevelt signed the Gold Reserve Act, and the next day a proclamation cut the gold content of the dollar by what the Treasury called "about 41 percent."
Timeline
| Date | What the record says |
|---|---|
| March 6, 1933 | The President declares "a bank holiday." |
| April 5, 1933 | President Roosevelt signs Executive Order 6102. |
| August 28, 1933 | A new executive order revokes the April 5 and April 20 orders but keeps every liability under them alive. |
| September 18, 1933 | Last day for filing returns under the Treasury's regulations; Campbell filed none. |
| October 5, 1933 | A superseding indictment adds a second count against Campbell: keeping his interest in the gold without a license. |
| December 28, 1933 | The Secretary of the Treasury issues an order of his own and sets the deadline at midnight of January 17, 1934. |
| January 2, 1934 | The bank surrenders Campbell's gold to the Treasurer of the United States, on an order from the Secretary of the Treasury. |
| January 30, 1934 | Roosevelt signs the Gold Reserve Act; the next day a proclamation cuts the gold content of the dollar by what the Treasury called "about 41 percent." |
| February 1934 | The Washington Daily News reports that the Supreme Court dismissed the government's appeal in its gold hoarding case against Campbell, on the motion of Solicitor General Biggs. |
| June 1934 | The federal appeals court in New York affirms the dismissal of both of Campbell's lawsuits. |
| October 1934 | The Washington Daily News reports that the Supreme Court had rejected Campbell's appeal and that he was still "under indictment for hoarding"; the court record says otherwise. |
| February 18, 1935 | The Supreme Court decides the Gold Clause Cases. |
Sources
Every statement above comes from a claim that two independent fact-check passes matched to one or more of these sources. Official records are listed first; each is labeled by kind. Open them to read for yourself.
- Annual Report of the Secretary of the Treasury, FY1934 (Official record)
- Executive Order 6102 (Apr. 5, 1933) (Official record)
- Executive Order 6260 (Aug. 28, 1933) (Official record)
- Proclamation 2072 (Jan. 31, 1934) (Official record)
- White House statement on Proclamation 2072 (Jan. 31, 1934) (Official record)
- Campbell v. Chase Nat. Bank, 5 F. Supp. 156 (S.D.N.Y. 1933) (Court record)
- Campbell v. Chase Nat. Bank, 71 F.2d 669 (2d Cir. 1934) (Court record)
- Campbell v. Medalie, 71 F.2d 671 (2d Cir. 1934) (Court record)
- Norman v. Baltimore & Ohio R. Co., 294 U.S. 240 (1935) (Court record)
- Nortz v. United States, 294 U.S. 317 (1935) (Court record)
- Evening Star (Washington), Sept. 28, 1933, p. 8 (editorial) (News report)
- Washington Daily News, Feb. 12, 1934, p. 4 (News report)
- Washington Daily News, Nov. 18, 1933, p. 20 (News report)
- Washington Daily News, Oct. 8, 1934, p. 1 (News report)
- Evening Star (Washington), Sept. 27, 1933, p. 1 (AP) (Source)
- Gold Reserve Act of 1934 (48 Stat. 337) (Source)
Further reading
Books on the same subject, listed by title for readers who want more background. We have not read or tested every item listed.
- Sebastian Edwards, American Default: The Untold Story of FDR, the Supreme Court, and the Battle over Gold (2018)
- Barry Eichengreen, Golden Fetters: The Gold Standard and the Great Depression, 1919-1939 (1992)
- Milton Friedman and Anna Jacobson Schwartz, A Monetary History of the United States, 1867-1960 (1963)
These notes are history and public records, not financial, legal or tax advice, and they say nothing about what any item is worth.