U.S. Bank Suspensions, 1930 to 1933: What the Records Show
The FDIC's table of commercial bank suspensions lists 1,350 for 1930, 2,293 for 1931, 1,453 for 1932 and 4,000 for 1933.
Watch (short film): The $8,000,000 Announcement, Then the Run on Gilt & Graft
The short version
The FDIC's table counts commercial bank suspensions, and it starts in 1921. According to the FDIC's history, an average of more than 600 banks a year failed between 1921 and 1929, ten times the rate of the decade before, and the table lists 659 for 1929. Nationwide deposit insurance had not yet been adopted; the FDIC's history says that happened in 1933. In the table, 1930 is the year the count jumps, from 659 to 1,350 suspended banks. Those banks held $837,096,000 in deposits, and depositors bore $237,359,000 in losses. When a bank closed in 1930, no federal deposit insurance stood behind its deposits. The FDIC's history says the earlier ambivalence about bank failures disappeared after a wave of failures in the last few months of 1930, which triggered widespread attempts to convert deposits to cash.
The table lists 2,293 suspensions for 1931, with $1,690,232,000 in deposits at those banks and $390,476,000 in losses borne by depositors. Against the 1921-to-1929 average of more than 600 a year, that is, by simple arithmetic, more than three times as many. Taking all of those banks together, the 1931 losses came to about 23 cents on the dollar of deposits by our own calculation; that is not a figure for any one bank.
In January 1932, the history says, a new federal lending agency, the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, was created, and one of its primary functions was to make advances to banks. For 1932 the table lists 1,453 suspensions, with $706,187,000 in deposits and $168,302,000 in losses borne by depositors. The history says the generally improved banking situation during the ensuing months was marked by a significant drop in both the number of bank failures and depositor losses, but waves of failures still occurred during the year. Later that year, Nevada proclaimed the first statewide moratorium, when runs on individual banks threatened to involve banks throughout the state.
The FDIC history says banking conditions deteriorated rapidly in the winter of 1932 to 1933, with state after state declaring bank holidays, and the crisis peaked in the first three days of March 1933. By March 4, Inauguration Day, every state in the Union had declared a bank holiday, the history says. At one o'clock in the morning on March 6, President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed Proclamation 2039, ordering all banking institutions in the United States to keep a bank holiday from Monday, March 6, to Thursday, March 9, both dates inclusive. For 1933 the table shows 4,000 suspensions, with $3,596,708,000 in deposits and $540,396,000 in losses borne by depositors.
The House met at noon on March 9, and the FDIC's history says it passed the bill, H.R. 1491, after only forty minutes of debate; the Senate approved it intact several hours later. The statute's last line records its approval on March 9, 1933, at 8.30 p. m. The Banking Act of 1933, approved on June 16, 1933, created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. The FDIC's history says insurance of bank deposits became effective on January 1, 1934, and that the fund opened with 13,201 banks insured or approved for insurance.
Adding the table's four years, 1930 through 1933, gives about $6.83 billion in deposits at suspended banks and about $1.34 billion in losses borne by depositors, roughly one dollar lost for every five on deposit. The table gives the losses, but it does not say how long depositors waited.
Timeline
| Date | What the record says |
|---|---|
| December 12, 1930 | An Associated Press report in the Washington Evening Star said New York City was moving to recover, by legal action, $1,500,000 on deposit in the closed Bank of United States. |
| January 1932 | The Reconstruction Finance Corporation was created, with advances to banks among its primary functions. |
| March 4, 1933 | Inauguration Day: every state in the Union had declared a bank holiday, according to the FDIC's history. |
| March 6, 1933 | President Roosevelt signed Proclamation 2039 at one o'clock in the morning, ordering a bank holiday from March 6 to March 9, both dates inclusive. |
| March 9, 1933 | The House met at noon, and the law was approved at 8.30 p. m. |
| March 12, 1933 | The President spoke on the radio and said banks found to be all right would start reopening the next day in the twelve Federal Reserve Bank cities. |
| June 16, 1933 | The Banking Act of 1933 was approved and created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. |
| January 1, 1934 | Insurance of bank deposits became effective, and the fund opened with 13,201 banks insured or approved for insurance. |
Sources
Every statement above comes from a claim that two independent fact-check passes matched to one or more of these sources. Official records are listed first; each is labeled by kind. Open them to read for yourself.
- Roosevelt, Fireside Chat of March 12, 1933 (transcript) (Reference page)
- Evening Star (Washington), Dec. 12, 1930, p. 2 (News report)
- Banking Act of 1933 (48 Stat. 162) (Source)
- Congressional Record, vol. 77 (Mar. 4 - Apr. 3, 1933): House, March 9, 1933 (Source)
- Emergency Banking Act, March 9, 1933 (48 Stat. 1) (Source)
- FDIC, The First Fifty Years (1984), ch. 1: Introduction (Source)
- FDIC, The First Fifty Years (1984), ch. 3: Establishment of the FDIC (Source)
- Proclamation 2039, Bank Holiday, March 6, 1933 (48 Stat. 1689) (Source)
Further reading
Books on the same subject, listed by title for readers who want more background. We have not read or tested every item listed.
- Susan Estabrook Kennedy, The Banking Crisis of 1933 (1973)
- Milton Friedman and Anna Jacobson Schwartz, A Monetary History of the United States, 1867-1960 (1963)
- Barry Eichengreen, Golden Fetters: The Gold Standard and the Great Depression, 1919-1939 (1992)
These notes are history and public records, not financial, legal or tax advice, and they say nothing about what any item is worth.