The 1933 Gold Return Lists and the Court Cases That Followed

In 1933 the Federal Reserve Board asked for lists of people who had withdrawn gold and had not put it back in a bank, and gold-law cases later reached federal courts; no source found gives the total of gold kept.

Watch (film): Agents Seized $2,000 in Gold From a Man About to Board a Train on Gilt & Graft

Paper Trail: Paper Trail No. 11: Gold Return, 1933, a $6 PDF with every claim matched to its source.

The short version

The Federal Reserve Bulletin counted the run on the banks in early 1933, reporting that demands for currency between February 15 and March 4 added up to $1,630,000,000. Of that total, $300,000,000 was demands for gold coin and gold certificates, and three-fourths of those demands came in the week beginning February 27, with more than half in the first three days of March. On March 6, the President's proclamation barred banks from paying out any more gold coin or gold certificates. Two days later, the Federal Reserve Board asked the reserve banks to prepare lists of persons who had withdrawn gold and had not put it back in a bank.

The Bulletin reported that between March 4 and March 31, 1933, $260,000,000 of gold coin and $370,000,000 of gold certificates were returned to the Federal Reserve banks and the Treasury. The Associated Press told it another way, saying that $600,000,000 in gold and certificates came back in the first three weeks after the President declared hoarding was injuring the Nation, followed by a slowing down. On March 31, the Bulletin said, the gold and gold certificates still outside the Treasury and the reserve banks came to $760,000,000, the lowest figure since 1923. By April 30 the AP's estimate of what was still outside the Treasury was $800,000,000 to $900,000,000, a figure higher than the Bulletin's a month earlier, and the AP gave no source for it.

On June 6, 1933, the Evening Star carried an AP report that Department of Justice agents were beginning their calls on 1,000 persons. They were named on a Treasury list, the AP said, as suspected of holding more than $100 in gold each, and the AP put the total believed to be hoarded at $600,000,000. On July 27, the AP reported that Attorney General Cummings said a list of more than 5,000 persons known to have withdrawn gold was being checked, and that 207 persons had refused to return $1,231,086 of gold.

On December 28, 1933, the Treasury ordered gold coin, gold bullion and gold certificates delivered to the Treasurer of the United States. A supplementing order, on January 15, 1934, fixed the deadline at midnight on Wednesday, January 17. The Federal Reserve's own table carried a warning: the Treasury and the Federal Reserve banks stopped counting gold coin as in circulation, effective January 31, 1934, when the figure would have been $287,000,000. A footnote said the gold coin previously reported as in circulation "is known to have been overstated."

In August 1934, federal agents seized $2,000 in gold coin from a man about to board a train. The court held that title to the coins had passed to the United States on January 30, 1934, the day the Gold Reserve Act was approved, and on August 17, 1937, it granted the government's request to condemn them. In January 1935, a federal judge in Massachusetts ruled on two indictments, siding with the defendants on the second count, which charged owning or holding gold coin, and going the other way on the first, which charged failing to file the required return. A second case came out of Manhattan, where in April 1935 a government investigator walked into a gold-scrap shop open to the public. The trial court ordered the seized gold returned, finding that a warrant was needed, but on January 10, 1938, the Second Circuit reversed.

No source found for this page gives a total count of how many Americans kept their gold.

Timeline

DateWhat the record says
February 15 to March 4, 1933Demands for currency on the banks add up to $1,630,000,000, including $300,000,000 for gold coin and gold certificates, the Bulletin says.
March 6, 1933The President's proclamation bars banks from paying out any more gold coin or gold certificates.
Two days after March 6, 1933The Federal Reserve Board asks the reserve banks to prepare lists of persons who had withdrawn gold and had not put it back in a bank.
March 4 to March 31, 1933The Bulletin reports $260,000,000 of gold coin and $370,000,000 of gold certificates returned to the Federal Reserve banks and the Treasury.
April 30, 1933The AP puts what is still outside the Treasury at $800,000,000 to $900,000,000.
June 6, 1933The Evening Star carries an AP report that Department of Justice agents are beginning their calls on 1,000 persons.
July 27, 1933The AP reports Attorney General Cummings saying 207 persons had refused to return $1,231,086 of gold.
December 28, 1933The Treasury orders gold coin, gold bullion and gold certificates delivered to the Treasurer of the United States.
January 15, 1934A supplementing order fixes the deadline at midnight on Wednesday, January 17.
January 30, 1934The Gold Reserve Act is approved; a court later holds that title to the seized coins had passed to the United States that day.
August 1934Federal agents seize $2,000 in gold coin from a man about to board a train.
January 1935A federal judge in Massachusetts rules on two indictments.
August 17, 1937The court grants the government's request to condemn the $2,000 in coin.
January 10, 1938The Second Circuit reverses the trial court in the Manhattan case.

Sources

Every statement above comes from a claim that two independent fact-check passes matched to one or more of these sources. Official records are listed first; each is labeled by kind. Open them to read for yourself.

Further reading

Books on the same subject, listed by title for readers who want more background. We have not read or tested every item listed.

These notes are history and public records, not financial, legal or tax advice, and they say nothing about what any item is worth.